Watch out, LinkedIn: Facebook is gaining on you
Social networking site elbows in on LinkedIn's job-finding franchise.
When it comes to finding a new job, they say it’s all about who you know. With the rise of online social networks that has never been truer.
Today, 42% of adults in the U.S. with Internet access maintain a profile on a social networking site, up from 20% in 2007, according to Forrester Research. And in an economy where almost one-tenth of the population is unemployed, more job-seekers are likely to look for opportunities online.
Meanwhile existing members of social networks may take the time to fill in more of their job history in their profiles.
Recruiters have been scouring professionally-oriented social network LinkedIn for qualified candidates for years now. More than 40% of Fortune 100 companies pay to use the site to find talent among its 46 million members.
But social networks are still evolving as places to hire and be hired, and Facebook, with its 250 million members, is gaining ground.
Unlike its more career-focused competitor, Facebook offers members profiles that tend to reflect their whole life. In the past that deterred many who were concerned an incriminating photo or wall post might be discovered by a potential new boss.
Professional and personal lines blurring
That fear is going away as people become more comfortable sharing their lives online, sometimes even blending their personal and professional personas. Some users take advantage of Facebook’s privacy settings to edit the information they present to professional contacts.
More importantly, Facebook is gaining credibility as a tool for recruiters and human resources professionals, the very folks who've been avid fans of LinkedIn. For one thing, Facebook seems to cast a wider net and provide recruiters with more references – and more outlets to spread the news about a job opening. Facebook users have an average of 120 friends. While LinkedIn won’t release this statistic for its members, recruiters say the average number of connections likely is smaller because of the site’s narrower scope.
The types of relationships and contacts found in a personal network versus a professional one are also assumed to be more authentic and less transactional, and therefore more desirable to marketers. And while Facebook members now span all ages and demographics, the average age of its users is 31, compared to 41-years-old for LinkedIn.
These are aspects that attracted technology company EMC (EMC) to Facebook. “Many college grads aren’t on LinkedIn,” says Polly Pearson, VP of employment brand and strategy engagement at EMC. “We’re going where target market is—that’s why we’re on Facebook.”
Reaching recent college grads
As a business-to-business lacking strong consumer awareness, EMC relies on its Facebook page to build its reputation as a great place to work. It’s still too early to judge the success of EMC’s foray into social networking—the page only has 745 fans—but Pearson says the company has made hires through social networks and is more focused on starting a dialogue with potential employees.
“We have to have a huge pipeline,” explains Pearson. “A company can have a website all day long but there’s a lot more people hanging out on Facebook than on our website.”
As a technology company, EMC took a DIY approach to Facebook. But companies like the Pepsi Bottling Group (PBG), Harley Davidson (HOG) and Bally Fitness rely on CareerBuilder to develop a presence on social networks. The career site consults with 250 clients, helping them build Facebook community pages that incorporate job listings, blogs about applying for positions and discussions among candidates and employees.
“Companies are always initially afraid,” says CareerBuilder chief marketing officer Richard Castellini. “We’re trying to help them understand that by giving up control you’re still going to get benefits in terms of deeper and wider conversations.”
While active job seekers might visit the Facebook pages of companies they're interested in, Facebook also enables companies to reach target candidates who might not be looking. This more recent advance is made possible by Facebook Connect, a feature that enables websites and applications to access information in a user’s profile (with their permission).
Two Silicon Valley start-ups are deploying the feature to help companies encourage their employees to refer friends for open positions. Internal referral candidates are the most appealing to human resources departments since they are less expensive to find and tend to be the best fit for a position, meaning less turnover.
San Francisco-based Jobvite manages the entire hiring process for its customers, which include Tivo (TIVO), Mattson (MTSN) and Mozilla. The firm, which announced an additional $8.25 million in funding yesterday from ATA Ventures and CMEA Capital on top of an initial $7.2 million investment from CMEA in 2007, operates a “software as a service,” or SAAS, platform. Clients simply subscribe the service on a monthly basis, rather than paying to have the software installed on their own servers.
The name Jobvite originally referred to a feature that enabled clients’ employees to use Outlook to generate invitations to apply for jobs at their company. But that required employees to sift through their contacts themselves, assuming they even used Outlook as their source for email addresses.
In February the company created an application that used Facebook Connect to allow employees to send job invitations via Facebook. The app will even search the profiles of the employee’s Facebook friends to see who might make a good match for the job. The invite can then also be forwarded on to friends outside the original employee’s network. (The invite feature is also available for LinkedIn.)
“We help companies scale how they hire people through networks,” says Jobvite CEO Dan Finnigan, who spent five years at Yahoo's (YHOO) HotJobs unit prior to joining the start-up last year.
Appirio in San Mateo offers a similar invite feature as software-as-a-service, but only for customers of Salesforce.com (CRM). The firm, which is backed by Salesforce, Sequoia Capital and GGV Capital, offers applications that manage referrals in social networks, whether for hiring purposes or a marketing campaign. All the data is sent back to Salesforce for analysis and tracking.
If you’re fortunate enough to have a job right now, especially one you love, all of this may not seem especially relevant to you. But at some point in your career, you could simply be posting a status update when your next job comes looking for you.
Yeah, agree … facebook for kids and linkedin for industry professionals. I also recommend cestagi for those in academia.
not gonna fly – last thing I need is sharing my personal life on the net.
LinkedIn is way to go for a pro. Facebook is for kids.
There are some key advantages for both co's and individuals to use Facebook in addition to LinkedIn.
LinkedIn, at this point, allows very little interface between its activity stream and other sites. For example, I have my lifestream (aka website) on posterous.com (montageconsultinggroup.com) and when I find articles of interest to my clients, I post to posterous, which feeds out to twitter, friendfeed, and facebook. To put that same info on LinkedIn, where I do have many industry connections, I have to go to LinkedIn and post it. They are missing the boat on this one and hopefully will rectify with their upgrade.
Facebook has a lot of privacy checks in place. It is very easy to set up your page so that people see what you want them to see. You can link to your LinkedIn profile from there, as well.
There are also other options for job hunters to market themselves, using tools such as retagr, Google Profiles, Giza page, cardly, etc.
For many people, setting up a page on one of those sites might be the way to drive recruiters and co's to the page you want them to see. And if you want to make sure they can't find your Facebook or MySpace pages, simply set them up with an email address that you put on your resumes, but not the one you use with your friends.
Hope this helps.
We think social networking have a positive influence on moving to other areas or even countries. Is there research which can proof this.
Please send info to> vanelburg@rave-cruitment.com
As a business professional, I want to separate my business life from my personal life. I don't see why there would be a move to generic social networks such as facebook where this line too often gets blurred. Facebook has seen the downfall of many professional personas. I advocate business social networks such as incompany.com and linkedin.com over generic networks like facebook and myspace for businesses and professionals
I agree with Greg's comment. Facebook is more appropriate for personal networking, and LinkedIn for professional networking. Here's my take on the debate http://j.mp/3HKUKu
There are still a lot of people out there that have a dividing line between work life and personal life. While college kids may be on Facebook now, they will soon realize it is not a tool to manage professional relationships. LinkedIn does this very well by not including all the social noise that takes away from one's professional achievements. Businesses that want to know what to know what their employees are doing with family and friends while they are not at work should really think about how they are focusing their resources regarding this matter.
As for LinkedIn, from what I can tell they do a pretty bad job helping college students understand the value of using this tool. If I were hiring a student fresh out of school I would want to know if their professors recommend their work as a student. LinkedIn can help with this by using their recommendation tool. Also, when students leave college they have a head start on building a professional network that they can see three degrees away. That helps when looking for a job. You cannot do that with Facebook unless you have an additional app (and it is pretty ineffective).
Would be great to see LinkedIn support registration and login with OpenID (Google, Yahoo, AOL), Twitter, Windows LiveID and the importing of address books from Yahoo, Google, Plaxo, etc. as well as the ability to push activity stream back to the other social networks. That might give them a competitive advantage vs. Facebook.



Great, helpful article.
These days, job seekers need all the help they can get to rise above the crowd and get noticed first by prospective employers.
Toward this end, I thought I’d share with you a new, free tool I’ve created and launched to help job seekers: http://www.preverify.com
PreVerify is a free tool with which job seekers can conduct their own accurate and professional employment verifications. Following the quick and simple registration process, simply send your PreVerify request to your former and current employers to complete online at a time that is convenient for them to do so. No more interruptive phone calls, just an employment verification that can be used over and over again, forever.
Rather than crowd this email with a bunch of words, attached are two recent articles that talk about PreVerify:
http://www.prweb.com/releases/2009/08/prweb2645354.htm
http://www.killerstartups.com/Web-App-Tools/preverify-com-preverifying-employment-histories
Please feel free to View My PreVerify Profile: http://www.preverify.com/profile/michael-levine/1