Comments on: A must read: The iPhone's 'Untold Story'

By: Andrew Paul, El Paso, Texas

Andrew Paul, El Paso, Texas — Tue, 15 Jan 2008 21:05:12 +0000

Vogelstein is an arse. Why does Valleywag have to shorten the article? Because the article is crap. And the 378 words that are left over reek even more. "…his silence reportedly even more terrifying than his trademark tantrums." Please. Reportedly? Name one successful product that was created without some kind of "reported" difficulty. Wow… Apple spent money to make money. Unheard of!! The only way to satisfy an insatiable consumer appetite is to work your ass off, and produce produce produce. Tell me you've never heard a publisher or editor at Wired yell at their staff on a deadline. Dude, do you get paid to write this garbage? That's the real travesty here! Get an ilife, get a Mac, and be happy.

By: John Kantor, St. Petersburg, FL

John Kantor, St. Petersburg, FL — Mon, 14 Jan 2008 14:50:29 +0000

The difference between Steve Jobs and Bill Gates is that Steve didn't ship it anyway – and then let the consumers debug it.

By: Mike from Cleveland

Mike from Cleveland — Sat, 12 Jan 2008 13:25:12 +0000

"Slam doors, yell, take off for days", and that is what…bad? You people need a life, get into the real world, that happens and because it happens good things result. Jobs is the perfect example of what can occur when you challenge people to do their best, they make the best. The iPod, iPhone, Mac computers, OS 10.5, iTunes, iMovie, iDVD, etc…etc…etc…you don't get quality products like that by babying your people, if you can't take the heat, get out of the kitchen!!!

By: tomob

tomob — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 14:25:59 +0000

Look at how the iPhone changed the meaning of cool in cellphones:

http://humanvoice.wordpress.com/2008/01/10/iphone-changes-everything/

By: NY NY

NY NY — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 03:38:50 +0000

Yah…it’s an overpriced stock…yah right. One of the only stocks that actually has a PRODUCT(S) that everyone and their mother is buying. Look around LEN, and see how much Apple is EVERYWHERE, from every laptop, to MP3 player at the gym, to phones being used.

QUOTE!!!!!!!!

um, what planet are you from. nobody uses apple. every laptop every mp3 player, every phone??? what are you smoking. your less than 5% of anything and in this case including reality. and your really just a trend brought on by rich kids living an mtv dream.

on another note im smiling knowing i just built a super computer for about 1000 dollars, and you got an apple piece of crap for same price with 512mb of ram for probably same amount.

And for the guys that will argue better programming doesnt need more power. wake up. even if something sounds right, doesnt mean its true. As i become more capable of multi tasking and doing more with my pc, i demand more of my pc and as much as you apple people can keep it idiot proof and so simple my grandma can do it. truth is WE NEED POWER. and how come noone makes games for mac, cause nobodies using them. and sure bring up 5 examples of compatible games, ill bring up the million title library that isnt.

Yeah let apple keep telling you what a computer should do and how to do it. and by the way you can get an apple with similar specs to my pc. i think apple has one with similar specs in the 4 to 5 grand range. What a great company huh. i guess that means apples OS is worth about 4grand, yeah right. the only logical place I can see apples OS is for like refrigerators or like washing machine interfaces. when you seriously dont want to think its the perfect OS

and as a computer technician myself, i have to say fixing an apple, is 100 times harder than windows. once again apple would rather you replaced, they know you can afford it, since you already spent insane amounts on your first one. dont ever have an error, cause noone on earth will know what to do.

By: Frank Johnston, Lafayette, CA

Frank Johnston, Lafayette, CA — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 18:58:01 +0000

At it again "Elmer"? What is your point about $18t vs. $10…? That companies shouldn't make a profit??? You work for FORTUNE magazine…and Gates???? He has been swimming in the sweat and blood of so many underpaid, undervalued, software engineers for years now, only to the detriment of the market for that career! Give us a break, go buy a Porche and get it overwith!

ex ped: You misunderstand me. I have no agenda here. I'm merely pointing out a discrepancy between Piper Jaffray's analysis and Wired's reporting. And if I worked for Microsoft and not a Time Inc. publication, maybe I could afford a Porche.

By: Duncan Grant, Columbia SC

Duncan Grant, Columbia SC — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 18:22:19 +0000

What a great story! Insightful, well-written and best of all, very interesting. Congratulations.

Don’t know if you are interested but Bill Gates, some time well before the advent of the iPod or iPhone called Apple “that tiny little market share company.” I have often wondered if that incensed Jobs enough to push him over the edge and into development of these new products. If so, this would also make a great story.

By: JeremyB, Washington, DC

JeremyB, Washington, DC — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 17:54:23 +0000

With a few exceptions, Vogelstein avoids the oohing and aahing so familiar to legions of Apple fanboys. Instead, with energy and enthusiasm he weaves a story of secret meetings, slamming doors, and the mad rush to deliver a working iPhone, first for the folks at Cingular (now AT&T), then for public at the annual Apple love-fest, Macworld. "Untold" may be a stretch, but Vogelstein's conclusion that Steve Jobs "has given all the power to consumers, developers, and manufacturers," and that the carriers will benefit as people "spend more time on devices … racking up bigger bills," is pretty compelling.

By: Robert Hobkirk, Elk Grove, CA

Robert Hobkirk, Elk Grove, CA — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 16:50:50 +0000

Your title, "Must Read" got me to read it. Congradulations.

Interesting antedotes about a gizmo that the consumers are going ga-ga over. All the Iphone needs is a knife blade and it would be the ultimate Swiss Army knife.

By: Steve Mertz, Boulder, Colorado

Steve Mertz, Boulder, Colorado — Thu, 10 Jan 2008 16:37:58 +0000

As an undergrad I bought an Italian scooter from an old Shriner. It was fast and zippy. I rode it everywhere.

At the same time my best friend bought a Jeep. He liked to make fun of my choice of transportation. His jeep had 4 wheel drive and more power, and where would I be if it rained?, etc.

His jeep was always in the shop or belching blue smoke and it sucked down gas.

A cute girl at a party explained to him that she would rather ride home on the back of my scooter. "it's so fun!"

I have used a pc for years at work. Now I have a Mac. I use it for everything. It's fun.

Apple stock will do just fine.