Comments on: iPod sales now driven by style more than storage

By: Janus, Madrid, Spain

Janus, Madrid, Spain — Fri, 11 Jan 2008 15:48:57 +0000

@invalidname

The reason why people do not put their illegally downloaded movie collection on it is because the movies need reformatting first which may take a while to do. so many people are downloading movies, why should the numbers be wrong?

A 160GB hard drive is okay but a minority of people would need even an 80 or 30 GB music player if not used as a backup.

By: vpod_5g_and_shuffle_1g, bby, bc

vpod_5g_and_shuffle_1g, bby, bc — Tue, 23 Oct 2007 21:51:51 +0000

the article's a little off base, i think… sure, sales of flash-based ipods now are higher than hard-drive based ipods… but it doesn't take into account how many of these people who are buying the flash-based ipods *already own* a hard-drive based ipod.

the real comparison should be between first time ipod buyers… it wouldn't be entirely right to ask existing owners, either, because the hd-based ones were available first…

bottom line is, apple's making money hand over fist…

jf: Sales of flash-based iPods have so far outpaced hard-drive based iPods that it wouldn't be a meaningful comparison. The flash-based iPod nano has been the best-selling model for a long time.

By: Gman, Burbank, CA

Gman, Burbank, CA — Tue, 23 Oct 2007 00:47:47 +0000

I think that the iPod plays an important part of certian life styles and thus speaks to it's popularity.

I see iPod Nano's at the Gym, School, and at Airports – the size and playing time of the device is very important. The flash drive are also big enough to hold enough music so you don't get bored from lack of selection. You do not see many people use it to store calanders or phone numbers, the PDA thing is strictly business not pleasure.

By: adam chicago il

adam chicago il — Mon, 22 Oct 2007 19:33:07 +0000

Yadgyu-

"People do not have 160GB of good music to listen to. "

i odnt htink that is true at all. many people have that much music ,or more. its only a mtter of time before there is a 160 gig flash ipod avlaible. bigger storage is always better as long as it is priced right.

also consider more and more people are choosing to keep higher quatliy music on there pods taking up more space. i see a time when people are storing there flac files in a ipod.

when the price of solid state memory comes down you will see high capiacity apple products.

By: Jason Somerville, MA

Jason Somerville, MA — Mon, 22 Oct 2007 17:19:40 +0000

Personally, I think that the iPod touch is so popular because it is flash based. The price isn't the selling factor, it's the storage medium. I can't tell you the number of times I've locked up my iPod or caused music to skip when I jostled it while the memory buffer was being fed. At 16 GB, the iPod touch is getting near to the 20 GB models that Apple used to sell, plus it doesn't suffer from the problems of a rotating hard drive. As it is, I think the fact that 16 GB of flash can be had for a reasonable price is why Apple is seeing competition from the likes of SanDisk.

By: I dont give a Woot,Ny

I dont give a Woot,Ny — Mon, 22 Oct 2007 17:05:42 +0000

Refurbished Zune(s) can be had for as little as $80 refurbished (hint: woot)

They have wifi, but sadly no browser as of yet.. perhaps adding these functions as well as more codecs can sway tech savvy consumers. Yes, we all know how difficult it is to navigate on a mini portable device, but if anyone can COME LATE TO THE BROWSER PARTY, it's Microsoft!

By: SC , Detroit, MI

SC , Detroit, MI — Mon, 22 Oct 2007 16:42:12 +0000

my, gosh, that little thingy looks so delicate, with my self, i could me breaking it after two weeks.

i would definitely choose the ipod hard drive model. songs are nice, but its audiobooks, self-hynosis programming intensives, audiodramas and radio shows are what i would want to include on it.

By: invalidname, Marietta, GA

invalidname, Marietta, GA — Mon, 22 Oct 2007 16:23:28 +0000

Might it also have to do with the fact that downloadable video still isn’t easy to come by? While Apple has millions of songs available for purchase on iTunes, Hollywood studios have been less eager to offer their video libraries to Apple. Well, that's interesting when you consider that a) the entertainment industry considers iPods and the like to be a tool of piracy, assuming most of their contents to be ill-gotten, and b) movies and TV shows, ripped from DVDs or captured off broadcast, are quite easy to find online. If there's not as much demand for high-capacity iPod Classics, and if that's an indication that people don't need as much space for their mobile video, then maybe that in turn suggests that the claims of video piracy are overblown. If it's easy to get all the movies you want, for free, off the internet, and fill a 160 GB classic with them, and if people aren't actually doing so, then maybe Hollywood's rhetoric is overblown.

FWIW, I replaced a 10 GB iPod and decided that novel as the touch is, that 16 GB was too small. So I got the 160 GB classic, figuring it was pretty future-proof, at least capacity-wise. I ripped my 700 CD collection and didn't even fill half the classic. Even with video podcasts and a few TV shows from iTunes, I'm still not half-full.

By: Yadgyu, Harkeyville, TX

Yadgyu, Harkeyville, TX — Mon, 22 Oct 2007 15:59:12 +0000

People do not have 160GB of good music to listen to. People usually play about 50 songs on a regular basis and switch songs as needed. Plus the iPod touch looks cooler than the other ones. The cool factor heavily outweighs the storage capacity.

By: Richard Green, Apex NC

Richard Green, Apex NC — Mon, 22 Oct 2007 15:40:49 +0000

Style? how about Style and Funtionality! The I-Touch offers web browsing and on the fly downloading with a direct connection to I-Tunes. The I-POD classic offers a little more eye candy than its 5th gen older sibling but doesn't offer more functionality – just more storage space.